I played SWG from 04' up until about 6 months ago. The game was at its best when the learning curve was at its highest margin. Every veteran that played SWG then, could easily describe a dumbing down of the game to cater to the WoW crowd.
These kids came in screaming "Balance" and that was the end of the fun. No more death penalties, no more elite crafting(still better than 95% of other MMO crafting systems to be honest) & everyone could be a Jedi all of a sudden in a time frame for which there should have only been a few.
Overall, I think it was a great game, even in the end.
The last year has been a fiasco with all the server transfers obliterating some servers and lagging the hell out of others making both unplayable. This game was fun without bleading edge graphical eye-candy and the SWGEMU team is making alot of effort to re-produce that game. I will be keeping an eye out for the official EMU release... someday.