So the Alan Wake series are completely different than Control right? The protagonists don't have any super powers like levitation or evade or launch? I was planning on getting Alan Wake 2 until I found out it was an Epic exclusive.
They're similar in the type of enemies you face, but as far as I recall there was only one boss that levitated in AW2 (none in AW 1), and no, protagonists in AW don't have super powers. You play as AW himself in the first one, and the only weapons you have to do anything slightly out of the ordinary with are flashlights, torches, flash bangs, etc, which strip the dark cloak away from the enemies to make them vulnerable to gunfire, or kill them outright. You play mostly as Saga, a female detective in AW 2, and some as AW. There's a TON of tedious gathering and posting of evidence photos as Saga, and what was annoying to me about it is the only puzzle work is placing them in their proper spots on the board.
Once you get all photos in a set placed, she acts as if she's suddenly figured out that part of the case, despite having the photos in her possession for some time. Maybe I'm nit picking there, as it's probably different to see them laid out together, but many others did complain about it too. It's just a part of the game that's very time consuming and feels like padding.
One of my fave ways of killing tougher enemies in AW 1 was to lure them into broken power lines. Any time you see a broken high voltage wire swinging and sparking in that game, you know it's an ammo saver. The original has far more outdoors segments in deep, dark woods, and they are often quite scary.
AW2 DOES have some scary dark forest segments too, but not enough of them IMO. It also has it's share of really strange, campy indoor stuff that just seemed far too silly to me. The train tunnel segment in AW2 early on is fairly good, it can be dark and scary in places, but the immersion is kind of also broken by tedious route finding.
BTW, after untracking The Enemy Within side mission, and backtracking to pursue the main mission to find Dylan, I went back to The Enemy Within with Evade, and I STILL had the game crashing at a certain point in the boss fight with Anchor. I'm really POed at Remedy right now, and I can see why this game has been given away free on Epic Game Store.