I played a Rogue up to 60, here's my impressions:
I have a career and a girlfriend, and we were both fighting over who gets to play (we shared an account). So, that isn't good.
It is addictive. Designed to create SEVERE need to upgrade equipment and weapons at every turn, because other RL players gank you or the monsters are too tough or too many, so you are always addicted to upgrading. Kinda like computer equipment LOL.
The music is cool and moody, the fighting in it isn't turn-based which is just silly, and the weapons are cool. Putting poison on daggers is more fun than watching Ad TV.
I am guessing it is just a real substitute for televison to relax and have fun, I mean, if you watch TV and WoW, maybe that's psychological.
Also, to be objective, I do think that the way corporate life is structured people don't have any fulfillment at the job. You log into your workstation, log out and go home.
I could always argue that skydiving AND eating pizza at the same time could be "more fun" too. Or 2 chicks at the same time. While skydiving. But, most people are just, frankly, fed up of TV and the massive amount of Ads.
The game is well developed-for, has great character design and equipment, but, come on:
This game needs a SEVERE graphical overhaul at this point for what they are charging for the game and the subsequent monthly fees.
I made 60, had fun in the auction house, and stopped playing one day. Just stopped, couldn't stand to play one more second. Kinda like the Clockwork Orange "treatments". I get sick to the stomach thinking about playing again.
Also, the monthly fees get bothersome after a while. And the grinding. I mean, who runs home to sharpen knives for 6 hours. It was a bit much.
So, my theory: People have unfulfilling jobs today. I mean, who gets to snowshoe around and shoot deer to make a living today? I mean, I wouldn't play ANY computer games at all then.
My second theory is it is just how bad TV has become. I mean, grinding in WoW or channel surfing Tampax ads?
Just my .02$