Archived from groups: comp.sys.ibm.pc.games.rpg (
More info?)
Mean_Chlorine wrote:
> Thusly David Carson <david@eldergothSPAMTRAP.com> Spake Unto All:
>>Did you play Warcraft 3? I thought WoW did a fine job of translating the
>>art style of that game into an over-the-shoulder heroic perspective,
>>rather than a god's-eye-view perspective.
>
> I guess one could make that point, in that WC3 had bright colors, low
> level of detail, and exaggerated models. However, WoW's been cutefied,
> and in WC3 the exaggerated models made sense, as you otherwise
> couldn't see what was going on, the models being basically scurrying
> ants on the screen.
True, the exaggerated models are not necessary in WoW the way they were
in Warcraft 3. But I'm certain they're there to maintain the flavour of WC3.
>>It's definitely an exaggerated cartoonish art style (although I wouldn't
>>have said "cutesy"), which will not be to everyone's taste, but so was
>>Warcraft 3.
>
> Not cutesy?
>
http://wow.rpgstars.com/screenshots/large/ss001.jpg
>
http://www.gameplanet.co.nz/images/mag/Features/Pictures/0001667,02.jpeg
>
> And look here, mr. & ms. Ratchet:
>
http://wow.rpgstars.com/screenshots/large/ss037.jpg
Hmm, nope. Cutesy is not the word I'd use to describe any of those
images.
🙂
Compare that to, say, Ratchet & Clank:
http://images-jp.amazon.com/images/P/B000070G2E.09.LZZZZZZZ.jpg
Cute little anthropomorphised animal, big manga eyes, big smile.
Or Jak & Daxter:
http://www.xboxcovers.net/covers_ps2/Jak%20and%20Daxter-Precursor%20Legacy%20%5Bntsc%5D.jpg
Huge manga eyes, another cute anthropomorphised animal with an even
bigger grin.
THAT'S the sort of thing I have in mind when I hear the word "cutesy",
and I don't think WoW is really in that league.
🙂 I think the WoW art
style is a much more stern and "tough" style of cartoonishness.
Cheers!
David...