Right, sorry I didn't make things clear. The fan is broken as in the head of the fan snapped off from the body, so it can't be used anymore. The reason that it's idling at 90 is because at some point my card must have gotten so hot that it messed up the thermal paste. I took the heat sink off before and the stuff was all over the place. I cleaned it off entirely, so currently I'm running the card with no thermal paste on that GPU (bad, I know). My computer is off most of the time at the moment though, and I'm not doing anything graphics intensive.
Currently, I'm waiting to reapply new thermal paste until I know what I'm doing to fix the card. If I'm getting a new heatsink, I don't want to have to buy more thermal paste. It should be alright though, because I'm leaving for a week today, so my computer will be off. Hopefully by the time I'm back I'll know what I'm doing.
I know there was a guide up somewhere about someone putting some VF900s on their 4850X2, but they didn't cool as well under load as the stock fans, so I don't really want to do that.