ATI Radeon HD 5830 Fills Price/Performance Gap

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.

dertechie

Distinguished
Jan 23, 2010
123
0
18,690
[citation][nom]mousemonkey[/nom]So what was the 4770 then? What was it based on? Where is the GT230 and GT215? and a GTS250 and 9800GT are so identical what with one having 112SP's and the other having 128SP's.[/citation]

The 4770 was a 40nm die shrink of RV770, and ATI makes this perfectly obvious. The name is not misleading. If they were to rename the 4770 as the 5650 and sell it as that, we'd be all over them for it.

The 9800 GTX+ and the GTS 250 are practically the same card. The differences between RV770 and Evergreen/RV870 are larger than the difference between those cards. NVidia's rebadging seems designed to mislead their customers. The GTS 250 moniker should mean it has the same architecture as the rest of the 2xx series (GT200 derivatives), which it doesn't. Throw in the fact that the mobile GTX 260/280/285 cards are also G92 derivatives and it's no wonder we don't trust them.

TL;DR, NVidia has a history of less-than-fully-transparent naming schemes. ATI less so.
 
The 9800GTX+ and GTS250 are the same card and I made a post a while back in the Graphics forum about why I thought they might have ended up with such a mishmash of names and cards, as for why people can't get their heads around the fact that two different companies have different ways of naming their products, that I've about given up on because there is no way to please everyone, so long as I can work out which is which the rest of the world can go hang.
 

shreeharsha

Distinguished
Jul 10, 2008
80
0
18,630
I was waiting to replace my 4 year old Radeon X800 XT card for a long time. Now I have found my card, since it a Radeon HD 5870 card (physically) I will definitely buy this card (It will be around INR 13,000).
 

bstm300

Distinguished
Jun 16, 2008
33
0
18,530
These numbers are garbage. The 5850 isn't worth more than $250 and the 5770 isn't worth more than about $130. I just feel terrible for all the suckers that are getting conned so much money for such little performance. I upgraded, or rather downgraded, from a GTX 260 to a $150 5770 with a drop in 5-10 f.p.s.! I should never have bought it to begin with. I shed a tear for the noobs spending upwards of $350 for the 5870 and the 5970.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.