Which one would you pick ?
Which one i'd pick, is based on my knowledge of MoBos, brand history and personal preference (e.g MoBo features, aesthetics).
For myself, #1 brand is MSI, since i already have several MSI MoBos and GPUs in use. Heck, even my monitor is MSI. Though, if in this price bracket there isn't a MSI MoBo that i'd like, #2 choice would be Asus.
Out of the previously linked, with up to $250 and DDR4 RAM slots, i'd go with: MSI PRO Z690-A DDR4,
specs:
https://www.msi.com/Motherboard/PRO-Z690-A-DDR4/Specification
It doesn't have on-board wi-fi, since i don't need it. I have cable connection. So, no point for me to pay extra for a feature that i don't use. Also, it doesn't have on-board RGB LEDs, which i don't mind. It also has 4x M.2 slots, giving me plenty of expandability to use only M.2 NVMe SSDs in my build. And it's all black aesthetics can combine with any color build, except all white.
Now, like i said, this choice is based on my preferences, which may not align or even match yours.
Regarding other choices in that price bracket, including Asus, many MoBos have white heatsinks on a black base. And to me, i don't care how good MoBo could be, i just don't like that kind of color combination at all. So, all those white heatsink MoBos are instantly removed from my choice.
So, to pick a MoBo from that small selection, read MoBo specs to learn what features they have and filter the selection down, based on the features you need. Then, when you have 2-3 MoBos left, look up the reviews (if there are any) and move on from there.
I have checked a YouTube video comparing fps in different mobos same specs and there was fps difference reaching to 20 fps xd
Care to link that video for us to see as well?