Is the processor correctly identified (8086K) upon power on self test when hardware summary is shown early in power on display?
As the other poster above correctly noted, I can only pray you did not think a factory provided cooler from an 8400, inadequate even for the 8400 itself under gaming loads, would even remotely be sufficient for an 8086K...
SImply swapping CPUs and powering on thinking /hoping it will all just work itself out in Windows with regards to cores/thread detection is also suspect...
How many cores/threads (logical processors) are currently shown in task manager/performance?