Is this pathetically simple thing really the best?

Habeed

Distinguished
Jan 28, 2007
50
0
18,630
I was browsing Frosty Tech's reviews of conventional heatsinks. I'm not sure how much better water cooling or thermoelectric is. Anyways, I came across this pathetically simple one : http://www.frostytech.com/articleview.cfm?articleID=2233

It is number 1 on one of their benchmarks, and in the top 5 on most. It's also almost the quietest one.

So : super quiet, works as well as any conventional heatsink can work. Heck, I don't even know if water cooling can do much better, even water cooling can only cool to a temperature somewhat above ambient.

And all it is is 3 heatpipes, and a big fan.

Neat. So would you guys recommend this heatsink? Its under $40 on newegg, making it super cheap as well as all of the other good qualities.

I just noticed it's one of the best reviewed top sellers, as well, so I guess I'm probably the last one on these forums that figured this out.

Still, it seems kind of lame that a device with 3 heatpipes and just 1 fan is better than all the other monstrous coolers out there. Heck, there's one that has a water pump, a fan, AND a peltier cooler all in one device...that doesn't cool under load very well at all.

I guess it's like on BBC's Robot Wars, where the "Wedge" robots generally dominated the field over vastly more sophisticated machines.
 
The answer to your question is yes. It is a good cpu heatsink.

There was another thread yesterday about manufacturers supersizing cpu, chipset, and mosfet heatsinks. It has reached the point where the components are getting in each other's way. It appears to be marketing hype more than anything else. Sometimes simple is better.
 

assasin32

Distinguished
Apr 23, 2008
1,356
22
19,515
Funny how the simple yet unsophisticated things work good.

BTW I never did look at heat sinks being simple, for some reason I always broke it down as into whats conducting the heat from the heat source and than what is that being absorbed by that and than expelling it away, etc. Safe to say we look this thing from a completely different angle.