While I think the idea of this is awesome (Plus 1 for Quake 2, MY favorite Quake installment...) I think this is one case that actually has some merit...
Quake 2 was also my all time favorite. They should settle it on the map called "The Edge" with railguns only. I'd play on Bethesda's behalf. I used to be like the Angel of death in the day with a railgun and a grappling hook.