Jarred you absolutely called Nvidia out BUT I think your star rating needs a tweak even by your standards/definition. When a new product launches and it is inferior in some ways (mem bus, lower vram than users would like, etc) to the last gen part and if noticable falls short because of this, even if it can grab some wins at 1080P this doesn't translate to a C grade. Its C- at best if not a D, IMHO. I think thats where your critics have a point even if it is splitting hairs to a degree. Objectively speaking this was a 3 star product by your definition and what I have seen in other reviews. And while your testing did show it trading blows with a 3070, unforuntely there are a lot of reviews out there showing it not beating or tying/beating (single digit percentage gains) the 3060 Ti under to many conditions. I don't know or not whether that may use some addressing on your part or theirs (notably Hardware unboxed and GamersNexus showed very poor 1440P numbers compared to 3060 Ti, though it did beat it). I know games tested can matter because I have no reason to dis-trust your data points.
People implying you're a sell out or simping for Nvidia are just plain wrong. You're clearly not happy with the product for how much it is and what we get. People getting super bent out of shape over what ends up being a half star is a tad much IMHO. I do think however the 4060 Ti needs to be dug into more thoroughly to figure out the dependencies between outlets.
Also I am a bit ashamed of the amount of hate your getting in this forum (criticism is fine). I may not agree with your review 100% but there is not call for all that either
I think there's way too much sensationalism these days within the YouTuber and journalism realms. Everyone wants a huge
<Mod Edit> rather than a reasonable take. I disagree, vehemently, with that approach.
RTX 4060 Ti is
not a bad card. It's not awesome, but to suggest it's a failure is hyperbole of the worst form. I wouldn't suggest everyone rush out to buy it, but I would absolutely recommend buying a 4060 Ti for $400 over a previous generation card with similar performance for the same price. Now, what about a "lightly used" RTX 3060 Ti for $300 or less? That's where it gets fuzzy.
I'm know there are select workloads where the 4060 Ti can perform a bit worse than a 3060 Ti, but my experience is that those are far from the norm. And while I don't love DLSS 3, it's not actually horrible. It's just overstating things, for lack of a better way of putting it.
As hotaru251 puts it, the idea that we should get 30 to 50 percent more performance each generation thanks to Moore's Law has long since died. TSMC N4
is expensive. Only Nvidia and TSMC know for certain exactly how much it costs for the GPUs, and Nvidia also has all the other components that go into the card to consider as well. Meanwhile, the economy is doing very poorly right now.
Nvidia could theoretically charge less money for the RTX 40-series cards and still earn money, but that's only if you look at hardware costs. What about all the R&D going on? What about previous generation GPUs that still need to be sold? I don't believe for a moment that Nvidia's CEO and executive team are blind to everything that's going on. Quite the opposite. I think they know far better than anyone on the web exactly what their portfolio looks like, how much inventory they have, how much they should charge, etc. Heck, they're probably running financial models that are smarter than all of us on their supercomputer to optimize profits.
This all reminds me a bit of my 13-year-old, where when he wants something, that's all that matters. Gamers want a faster, cheaper, better graphics card. Great! Wanting that and a company actually managing to create it are completely different things.
If you want another example... well, maybe check back in the morning. But AMD, the proverbial champion of the budget gamer, has abandoned the budget sector just as much as Nvidia. It's not making much money on previous generation RX 6000-series parts, RX 7000-series are only at the very top (and soon bottom) of the performance ladder, and pricing is basically right in line with what Nvidia is doing. There are tons of unsold last-gen GPUs as well, which is why AMD isn't pushing out RX 7800/7700 yet and instead is pointing at RX 6900/6800/6700-class GPUs.