QOTD: PlayStation Move or Kinect for Xbox 360?

[Guest]

kinect because ps move is just pretty much a wii with light bulbs and besides i dont like to get up while gaming if i wanted to get up i would go outside and play baseball or somthing not mlb 2k10

 

[timobkg]

Kinect is the more interesting and innovating technology. I hope it will turn into something awesome after a few years.

For actually playing games, Move is hands down better.

 

[bearracuda]

Move. I own all 3 systems and a PC and I gotta say, it doesn't seem like the kinect has very strong prospects for core gaming. Sure, you can pick up a prop and use it as a gun, but we have no idea how accurate that will really be for aiming, and I'm skeptical. Aiming aside, how will we be able to do all the other controls in an FPS? Without buttons, we'll end up looking like a retard AND taking 3-4 times as long to do the action.

And a lot of people seem to overlook that the playstation eye also tracks the body seperately of the move. So you -can- control more than just the character's arms and hands. You've got almost all of kinect's capabilities, and increased capabilities on everything that the wii offers.

Plus, game lineup: They've already converted a couple old games to be compatible with move, and have several more on the way that are in development specifically to use the move. (Hardcore games, not just casual) And those titles, plus titles not compatible with the move are being developed in 3D (not just upscaled) So, even aside from motion control capabilities, it just seems more viable to invest in the PS3 right now.

 

[nottheking]

Neither, I'll stick with the Wii. I mean, on one hand, Kinect requires an ADDITIONAL $150, while Move requires an ADDITIONAL $80 per player, so $160 for two people to have the complete controller setup.

Given how add-on accessories ALWAYS have a history (and will forever havd a future) of being relegated to poor software support, (I mean, hey, why bother programming for an optional, expensive add-on accessory when you want the biggest market possible?) so neither will displace the Wii, which had the advantage of being default with the console.

 

[hcgame3r4life]

Move sucks ass its a wiimote with a fucking light bulb on it move cannot do voice commands and the whole thing about it taking your whole body into advisory is a complete sham Sony conference at E3 with Tiger Woods 11 for ex it was terrible with calculating what the guy was doing dont listen to everything you hear from them, but i will admit the games look better but they both suck for each system and as always the regular game line-up for Xbox looks better wining the hardore gamer yet again

 

[cambruv]

i dont know which one is better but i will find out at christmas i hope but if it was up to me i would choose the move