SB X-Fi Fatal1ty sound card vs Asus Z97M-Plus on board Crystal Sound 2 vs new card?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Darkmatterx

Distinguished
Apr 8, 2003
574
7
19,015
Title pretty much says it all. SB X-Fi Fatal1ty sound card vs Asus Z97M-Plus on board Crystal Sound 2?

I'm currently using the SB card because of the front panel it comes with and I have a pair of Sennheiser HD 558 Open Back headphones. These come with the large plug and an adapter so you can use the smaller more common jack that is used by MP3 players and phones. I also have a Logitech Z5300 (yes, that old) 5.1 sound system that I just took in to a shop to get 1 input port re-soldered and he told me the sound was still good for a set of PC speakers.

I'm asking all this and saying all this because I thought I would get better sound through the big jack port in the front panel of the X-Fi but the sound guy who fixed my Logitech 5.1 said that for the amount of watts I would need, the small connector is just fine.

So, if I don't need the front panel, then the on board sound becomes an option but I don't know the difference in quality of a newer on board sound device vs and older discreet sound card. There's also the less desirable (to my bank statement) of getting some current sound card but I wouldn't know what to get.
 
Solution
D
Probably the sound card is better if that's just Realtek. Now are your speakers and headphones good enough to tell a difference? Maybe. :)

Audio is very subjective. What sounds great to me might be terrible to you and vise versa. Go with the sound card. As long as you don't have driver issues and it doesn't start crashing your computer it's most likely better. Another mod has a high end Creative card and it crashes his system regularly. But that doesn't mean you'll have problems.
Guess thats the difference between my old card and new ones. Mine only has 1 port not used and it is for a mic. Even if the software allowed me to switch it to a headphone jack the ports are so close together that with the speaker wires in place I can't get the headphone adapter jack into the port.

I currently stream stuff from my PC to my Sony Bravia TV through an HDMI cord from the video card (Nvidia 1070) to my TV. I assume that my headphones connected to a new sound card would give me superior sound over the built in stereo speakers on my TV.