G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: rec.games.trading-cards.magic.rules (More info?)
I have what appears to be an easy question, but it actually made us think
for a little while. Here goes:
The other night in a draft, my opponent had a flipped Nezumi Graverobber
(Nighteyes, the Desecrator) in play. I had a Moonlit Strider in play. Combat
got tricky, and the Strider went to the graveyard, and I couldn't Soulshift.
Later on, he brought back my Strider from my graveyard (with the Nighteyes),
and it survived combat. However, after combat, when there were small spirits
in my graveyard, he was about to sacrifice the Strider to give one of his
creatures pro-White. Before he did, I stopped him, asking what on earth
would happen with the Soulshift. Turns out, he didn't need to do it, so we
avoided the whole situation, but here's what I think would have happened:
He sacs the Strider, gives another one of his creatures Pro-White.
Strider hits MY graveyard, Soulshift triggers.
I get to choose whether or not to soulshift, and if so, which creature to
bring back.
He said that *he* could choose whether or not to soulshift, but I disagreed.
I think he'd control the activated ability of the Strider, but once it hit
the graveyard, it became mine again, and I'd do the soulshifting.
Amiright?
--
KB
Briscobar AT gmail DOT com
I have what appears to be an easy question, but it actually made us think
for a little while. Here goes:
The other night in a draft, my opponent had a flipped Nezumi Graverobber
(Nighteyes, the Desecrator) in play. I had a Moonlit Strider in play. Combat
got tricky, and the Strider went to the graveyard, and I couldn't Soulshift.
Later on, he brought back my Strider from my graveyard (with the Nighteyes),
and it survived combat. However, after combat, when there were small spirits
in my graveyard, he was about to sacrifice the Strider to give one of his
creatures pro-White. Before he did, I stopped him, asking what on earth
would happen with the Soulshift. Turns out, he didn't need to do it, so we
avoided the whole situation, but here's what I think would have happened:
He sacs the Strider, gives another one of his creatures Pro-White.
Strider hits MY graveyard, Soulshift triggers.
I get to choose whether or not to soulshift, and if so, which creature to
bring back.
He said that *he* could choose whether or not to soulshift, but I disagreed.
I think he'd control the activated ability of the Strider, but once it hit
the graveyard, it became mine again, and I'd do the soulshifting.
Amiright?
--
KB
Briscobar AT gmail DOT com