cleeve
Illustrious
A serious gamer, maybe. But many people who come on these forums want to know which videocard is best for counterstrike; which is best for HL2; which is best for Doom; which is best all-round; which is best for RTS; etc, etc. Not everyone is hardcore.But any serious gamer will play A game(s) based on either Source or D3. Theres no way around it.
And alot of the hardcore gamers have a hardcore preference. Honestly, in your X850XT PE vs. 6800U scenario above, would you recommend the 6800U to someone with no budget limit who hates D3? For what reason? The 850XT PE would best it in almost everything else. Not to mention, what if they do play D3 casually... do you honestly think the X850XT PE would be absolutely unplayable at quality settings?
D3 isn't the only game out there. And even if it was, can you say with a straight face that you wouldn't be able to enjoy the game with an X850 XTPE?
Besides that, no, I personally wouldn't recommend the X850XT PE over the 6800U in <b>any</b> situation, except if the buyer had no financial limits and wanted the fastest HL2 card money could buy. In my opinion, anything over $500 is wayyy to much money to spend on a videocard setup, when $300 cards can play everything with AA & AF. but that's just me...
But there are probably many cases where I'd recommend the $441 X850 XT over the 6800U, however. And where I'd recommend the 6800U over the X850XT.
Most of the time, I'd probably recommend the 6800GT for AGP, and the X800XL for PCI-e. 90% the performance for 75% of the price.
There is no one-size-fits-all in the videocard world.
________________
<b>Geforce <font color=red>6800 Ultra</b></font color=red>
<b>AthlonXP <font color=red>3200+</b></font color=red> <i>(Barton 2500+ o/c 400 FSB)</i>
<b>3dMark05: <font color=red>5,275</b>