Archived from groups: alt.games.microsoft.flight-sim (
More info?)
On Tue, 19 Apr 2005 10:22:37 GMT, "Forum User"
<forum_user@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>Chris Curtis wrote:
>> "Forum User" <forum_user@ntlworld.com> wrote in message
>> news:Rw29e.10585$DU6.2657@newsfe1-gui.ntli.net...
>>> That totally ignores the way-more-important aspects of owning a
>>> monitor. A GOOD LCD is worth so much more than the best CRT.
>>> Why ?
>>> Because for 99% of games and 100% of sims, a GOOD LCD is perfect.
>>> But the most important aspect of a monitor is eyestrain - and for
>>> that, LCD's are 101% better than CRT's.
>>> Then you got things like peripheral image distortion, flatness,
>>> footprint, weight, portability, reliability and static dust build-up
>>> .... and that's just for starters.
>>>
>>>
>> mmm. can't argue with your last sentence, but regarding eyestrain?
>> Yes, LCD's are flicker free which is why they are perceived as being
>> better; but for those gamers and simmers using good graphics cards
>> (and most will be) they will be running CRT's at high refresh rates
>> where flicker won't be a problem.
>
>No, no, no, no, no !
>ANY refresh rate (ie - any CRT) causes eyestrain.
>Visibility has NOTHING to do with it.
>It's about the effect on your visual cortex.
>Spend even a few minutes at 120 MHz and you start noticing it straight away,
>if you're used to an LCD.
>Eyestrain is the NUMBER ONE reason I cannot use an LCD.
I have a 17" NEC 1760v MultiSync and right next to it is a 19" CRT.
In the shop I use a 19" CRT and there is one on my wife's machine as
well.
I have probably spent an average of well over 8 hours a day using
computers since 1987. Back then it was probably over 12 hours a day.
It still averages over 8 hours a day and that's for 7 days a week.
I much prefer the LCD and would say it has less eye strain than the
CRTs. No glare where reflections are a royal pain on the CRTs. OTOH
I've never noticed flicker and "I do" have a CRT and LCD side by side.
As I said I much prefer the LCD.
I do a lot of photographic work, programming, e-mail and news group
reading, plain old surfing, and a bit of simming. IRL I fly a high
performance airplane for play.
>
Roger Halstead (K8RI & ARRL life member)
(N833R, S# CD-2 Worlds oldest Debonair)
www.rogerhalstead.com
>
> I bought an Iiyama LCD 2 years ago
>> because of space limitations and am very pleased with it. But I
>> recently hooked up the old Iiyama CRT as well and in no way did it
>> suffer by comparison. I use a Radeon 9800XT.
>> Chris
>