Archived from groups: comp.periphs.printers (
More info?)
Burt wrote:
>A bit of confusion here, Maggie - Pigment based inks, used in several of the
>Epson printers, are more permanent than dye based inks which have been used
>in older Epson printers and are used in Canon printers. I have posted this
>info before, so for those who have already read it, please accept my
>apology.
>Inkjet printers have the potential to get clogged heads with their own brand
>inks as well as quality aftermarket inks.
>
But to a far greater extent with after market inks.
>The two major issues are 1) the
>quality of the aftermarket inks and cartridges
>
And since anybody can open a website and stick a made up label on what
ever they sell it is much more difficult to tell what you are getting.
Just look at the majority of websites hawking ink and try to find a
manufacturer's BRAND name that they are selling. If you do then please
post the results.
>and 2) the frequency with
>which you print. In addition, there is always some buildup of dried ink on
>the underside of printheads that can sometimes cause clogs with months or
>years of normal, regular use. Since you are interested in your supplies
>beyond just going to the store and buying original brand manufactured
>cartridges it would be a good idea to become more educated regarding these
>printers, inks and cartridges.
>
>Although few of the vendors advertise which
>inks they are selling,
>
Ask your self why?
>there are a few who do let you know. I have
>personally used MIS inks to refill Canon carts and have been very happy with
>the product (which I have been told is Image Specialist ink). Look through
>this newsgroup for posts by Ron Cohen and Taliesyn for info about their
>personal excellent experiences with third party inks. Following are a few
>sites that have excellent information by people who don't just give you
>their opinionated response - they have used these products successfully, and
>they also report when they have had problems. Neil Slade's info on Canon
>printers, papers, and inks is at
>http://www.neilslade.com/papers/inkjetstuff.html . Then follow the link he
>gives near the top of that site to http://www.nifty-stuff.com/forum/ for
>the forum on ink jet stuff. Lots of information there as well. It's a good
>idea to know how to trouble shoot printer problems that can occur with any
>ink and that information is on those sites. Sensient Formulabs inks are
>available bulk and also in prefilled cartridges, and this ink has quite a
>good reputation with people who have used it and reported on this and other
>forums. Formulabs ink is in cartridges sold by Alotofthings
>
Go to their website and you will not find an adequate description of
what they sell. Send them an Email and ask them why they do not
describe what they sell adequately and why they do not list the
manufacturer/formulator BRAND name on their site. At least with Canon,
Epson, and HP you have a respected brand name that is sold in all
marketing channels. Sensinet Formulabs may be OK but while possible, it
is difficult to buy a Formulabs ink cart or a bulk bottle of ink with
the Formulabs name on it. That is what is wrong with this unregulated
industry.
>(their Arrow
>carts, not Rainbow),
>
>Weink
>
This guy is a hawker who charges $2.00 less than why you can be the real
Canon inks for at Costco. And he defends this also.
>(carts that have the CRU id in their product
>listings), and, I have been told, Wiredbeans carts which are available on
>ebay.
>
Many people have had problems with Pay Pal on eBay.
>You can contact each of them to verify that their cartridges are
>filled with Formulabs inks before purchasing. Do sign in to the Nifty-stuff
>forum and ask any questions of them that you wish. They are very helpful.
>There are also some extremely helpful participants on this newsgroup as
>well, but you can also experience the invective and snide remarks of a few
>people on this NG that might tend to discourage you from pursuing this
>issue.
>
By all means, you should pursue this issue. Carefully evaluate their
website as to what they are really putting in writing for the masses so
you will really know what they stand for. One problem with even very
legitimate ink stores is consistency. Unless they are selling a real
BRANDED product from a responsible manufacturer, the seller can easily
and legitimately change their supplier and the user will ultimately have
a different product and may have a lesser experience. Remember, if they
can get a better deal then you might not get the same product time after
time.
Also, when purchasing prefilled carts the quality and manufacturer of
the cartridge ( part of the ink delivery system) may vary and it is
difficult to judge this as well. Be an really informed buyer.
>For information on Epson printers look up Arthur Entlich's posts on
>this newsgroup. I know that he also uses some aftermarket inks for his
>Epson printers and, if you buy Epson, you should email him about
>availability of third party inks for Epson.
>
>"Lady Margaret Thatcher" <Was_at_10_Downing_Street@bad_for_the_UK.org> wrote
>in message news:c35g61ddk28o4uiso8k2th603mhrasf8et@4ax.com...
>
>
>>We have been unable to decide between a Canon or an Epson photo
>>printer. We feel that our needs would be well met by an iP8500 or an
>>R1800, when it becomes available. We see advantages to each printer.
>>However, we are most concerned about the reported lack of permanence
>>in pigment-based printers.
>>
>>So, we have been wondering if there exists a reputable, quality
>>supplier of third-party _dye_ inks for Canon Pixma printers, including
>>the extra colors in the iP8500? And of course at a price that won't
>>bankrupt the national treasury.
>>
>>Is there any truth to the statement that only Epson (and therefore not
>>Canon) knows how to design a printhead that will not clog with a
>>dye-based ink? Or is this a scurrilous comment by a backbencher type
>>who is ignored by all right-thinking people?
>>
>>Maggie
>>
>>
>
>
>
>