Either cooler would work with a Ryzen 3600.
It does depend on you though, such as:
A)How often you change out parts - say, a cpu upgrade - and whether the cooler will still be adequate whenever that happens and for whatever it is.
B)Looks: entirely subjective. I can't help you there.
C)If you care about getting your bang for buck or not. Hybrid coolers are more expensive than the retail pricing suggests.
-The pump is an additional point of failure, and when it goes, you pretty much have to toss the whole thing out, save for the working fan(s). Most weren't designed to be serviced by the user.
-Best have a replacement cooler on hand for when the pump does go - anywhere from <1yr to 8 years - or go without the PC until you get the...