Game debate is old, and I've always found it kind of laughable, but I haven't been there in a LONG time, so it may have been improved since then. Regardless though, they can't do much when nobody has the game to test anyhow.
It will be interesting to see how this turns out. I've seen a lot of games before that had versions for the PS4 and Xbox variants, that had PC versions with WAY higher system requirements especially if it was a port that was badly done, but even when it wasn't.
I honestly don't see what could be so "laughable" about the site.
I've been using it for over 5 years. And it's been very helpful to me over the years.
Obviously not these days since I have a more than competent system that I don't have to worry about not performing well for still a while to come and so I haven't needed to bother checking my specs to the requirements of games.
Also because I have a much better understanding nowadays of gaming tech and the performance variances.
Here's another two screenshot, this time not from my phone, that shows how it works.
First one is the top where it shows my specs in my profile, along with giving these specs a rating.
(Oh, btw, you don't have to plug your specs in everytime you want to check requirements if you create an account and put your specs in there)
And second pic here shows how it does the green +% and tells you what your hardware is like in comparison to the system requirements in a fairly easy to understand way.
Obviously my specs are above the recomended (which is for high preset at 1080p 60fps)
So honestly, what's laughable to me, is how so many other sites even bother to stick around and post system requirements when a site like this does more than they do to actually help the individual get a basic understanding of how their hardware stacks up to said requirements.
Because the system requirements only tell you specific hardware, and to an individual who doesn't deeply understand enough of all the minor intricacies of this tech, and just likes to keep things simple in their lives and doesn't ever want to bother with learning too much about tech, this sort of thing is like a god send to those people.
Sure, the site as whole is kind of average with all the tech news articles and stuff that just regurgitate information just like nearly every other tech news place on the web, but that's not what I go there for.
I go there exclusively for the system requirements, and that's all.
And in that regard, I think they are the best place to go for them due to how they handle it for the end user.