Will this case do?

I would have gone with a full tower case, but that one will do. As long as it has a couple of decent fans (which that case does), and is not a hermetically sealed piece of plastic you should be fine.
 



I can still return it, any suggestions under $175-$200?
 
Check out the case roundup recently.

I personally like the Antec 1200 for that price range. I love the Antec 900 or 300 for mid tower and much cheaper.

You can check out the CoolerMaster Cosmos and Stacker cases as well.