From what I hear with PC Speakers (ie Z5500) you won't hear much of a difference between onboard audio and a Sound card but this is a question that is perplexing to me as I am getting ready to start on a Media only PC and have to answer some difficult questions myself.
Not to hijack your thread but I don't see the purpose of starting a new one that is going to ask the very same question.
Old System:
3 Carver Amps 2 TFM 35X and a 15
PreAmp Carver CT-27V
CD Player Carver 360
The 15 was stolen and one of the TFM 35X's is dead so I have left:
1 TFM 35X
Preamp
Carver 360
I'm going to take the one dead TFM 35X and make it the PC and I want to mod the Carver 360 and make it a Blu-Ray / DVD Drive.
So 1st question: Can you Mod an old CD Player so it can Blu-Ray Disks?
I could mod the Amp into a Media Server and then make the PreAmp a HTPC. Most of all I want to keep the looks and the sound of the past just upgrade it to current.
So should I keep the Preamp as it is or Mod it into a HTPC and make the one Amp a Server?
The speakers are kind of old but unbelievably powerful.
The front was Cerwin Vega 15's, Center was Cerwin Vega, and rear was Bose 401's. I want to keep the speakers so I'm going to have to get a 5 Out Amp which means I'll need two more rears which will probably be Bose 201's. I can probably get by with 100 Watts per speaker for the back 4 and Center plus finding the Carver Amp won't be hard.
If I can get by with just running straight from the PC to the amps (and still have surround) then the choice would be pretty easy to bypass the receiver/preamp as there wouldn't be a real need to do so. So do I need a Preamp or Receiver?
I did this early on while building my system by hooking the CD Player directly to the Amp.
If I can should I go ahead and move towards having a Sound Card?
With the above system would I need HDMI or can I get away with just a DVI to the TV? I haven't gotten a display yet as I use the computers for watching and recording right now.
The Pre-Amp in it's current condition has an S/PDIF input and 5.1 Dolby Surround (switch in the back made it 5.0 and I had no need or need a subwoofer) so should I just leave it alone and use the PreAmp?
If that's the case then the onboard should be fine as it's Digital to Digital and it wouldn't make a difference if I had a Sound Card or not... or am I wrong?
Now if I got a Sound Card could I use both the onboard and the Sound card at the same time? Such as listening to music in the shower while at the same time my kids could watch a movie in the living room all from one computer? Is that possible?
Lot's of questions and hopefully I can get them all straightened out here.