In my case, the problem was due to not having dual link DVI--only single link. Single link only supports 1920x1080. The tech spec posted on my retailer's site for my graphics card said it was dual-link DVI capable, but it is really only dual head capable via a DMS-59 connector, which Wikipedia says only supports single link DVI. Comparing the pinouts of DMS-59 and dual-link DVI confirms that it doesn't support the additional data lines needed for dual link.